The first book of queer theory I've read, so it feels a bit odd reviewing it as I don't have anything to compare it with. I got a lot out of it, though, and, apart from one chapter that went full-on post-structuralist (which rather went over my head) seemed pretty accessible.
Reviews and Comments
Bookish version of pdotb@todon.eu
This link opens in a pop-up window
pdotb commented on Beyond the Count by Margo Bond Collins
Not really a book to read through, but instead a source book for the study of vampires. Includes, among other things, Polidori's "The Vampyre" and newspaper/magazine articles about supposed real-life vampirism. Probably the last half of the book is entirely plays and poems about vampires, at which point I checked out.
pdotb reviewed The Historian by Elizabeth Kostova
Long. Just so, so long
2 stars
It would probably have been healthier if I'd given up on this 700-page monster at any of the many points at which I commented to others that it was like Dan Brown wrote a vampire novel. It just goes on and on. What's more, it's written in an odd first-person that has three (two? three? I forget now) narrators, which is resolved by making all but the teenage daughter's occasional appearances just the reading out of letters from older characters. Epistolary novels obviously have a fine heritage in the Gothic, most notably in Dracula, but at least those feel like real letters. These are letters that go on for twenty pages of excruciating detail. The only reason I can give for why I actually finished this is that I'm on a bit of a gothic/vampire 'thing' at the moment, but that's probably not actually a strong enough argument.
pdotb reviewed Carmilla and Laura by SD Simper
Felt a bit too similar to the original
3 stars
It's been a while since I read Carmilla, but this felt just a bit too similar. An enjoyable book all the same, and the places where it differs from Le Fanu's are largely improvements, but something still felt a bit off about it.
pdotb stopped reading Degrowth & Strategy by Nathan Barlow
pdotb reviewed Fake Facts by Katharina Nocun
Good discussion of a vital topic
4 stars
Helpful introduction to the topic of conspiracies in modern life. Mostly thematic chapters (e.g., climate change denial, sovereign citizens, and covid), but the last numbered chapter and the conclusion were particularly effective. The former talks about how to challenge conspiratorial thinking, including how to get friends and family members out of the rabbit hole, while the conclusion tackles the way conspiracies have seeped into mainstream political discourse and the dangers therein.
pdotb reviewed Red Rosa by Kate Evans
Text heavy for a graphic novel
4 stars
Pretty good introduction to the life and work of Rosa Luxemburg. Suffers a bit from cramming lots of text into the graphics. Nice touch, though, is that the text is related to her writings, either letters or books, as indicated in the endnotes.
pdotb reviewed The Socialist Register 2016 by Greg Albo
Mixed bag, but mostly really good
4 stars
Apart from the problematic takes covered in my earlier comment, and a couple of chapters that went way, way over my head (maybe if I was a polisci graduate, they might have made sense?), mostly good stuff. Particular highlights for me were the chapters covering countries outside Europe and North America, such as an explanation of the relationship between the BJP and RSS, or the history of the right in Japan. Also enjoyed the chapter that drew parallels between Rob/Doug Ford, Stephen Harper, and the Front Nationale :)
pdotb commented on The Socialist Register 2016 by Greg Albo
Content warning deadnaming, bad takes on mental health
Largely positive review incoming, but I wanted to point out that the penultimate chapter manages to both deadname Chelsea Manning, and to include this little gem: "'lone wolves' with mental problems". Ugh.
pdotb reviewed Harperism by Donald Gutstein
Good, concise overview of Harper's politics
4 stars
Content warning canpol
I have to confess to having been a bit oblivious to what was going on when Harper was in power, probably at least in part the result of having two kids under five, plus a lot else going on in my life. Now I'm trying to understand his time in office and this was a really good summary, with a chapter devoted to each of the ways in which he tried to remake Canada.
Most of the book concerns the weird symbiotic relationship between Harper and the CPC, the network of neo-liberal think tanks (e.g., the Fraser Institute), and the right-wing media (i.e., pretty much every newspaper :( ). This covers everything from the concept of 'economic freedom' (see also Poilievre's claim that he'll 'make Canada the free-est country in the world'), through suppressing environmental science that might get in the way of the oil industry, to denying income inequality by instead talking about 'income mobility'. Where the book really took off for me was in the last chapter, concerning Harper's neo-conservatism, in particular an increased focus on the military. Particularly grim was the way the CPC re-wrote the Chretien/Martin-era guide for the citizenship test to eliminate anything about the environment, peace, and social justice, in favour of Canada's experience of war.
In conclusion, a wide-ranging, if rather depressing, overview of the principal characteristics of Harper's politics.
pdotb reviewed The Armageddon Factor by Marci McDonald
Well, that was scary
4 stars
Content warning canpol, the Christian right
Kind of fits in with my current podcast listening, "Kreuz und Flagge", about the Christian right in the US, The Armageddon Factor traces the rise of the Christian right in Canada, funnelled through Preston Manning, Stockwell Day, and, especially, Stephen Harper. The author covers the organization of the Christian right, from TV and radio stations, through schools and colleges, to training for parliamentary assistants. The topics of concern include abortion, gay marriage, education, and creationism (among others), including the wild story of a school board in the interior of BC which had been teaching creationism for ten years without the province realizing! Not a fair criticism of the book, as such, but it's written during the Harper years and so obviously doesn't cover more recent developments.
pdotb reviewed Climate Strike by Derek Wall
Takes an interesting turn
4 stars
Up to about the halfway point I was thinking to myself that I've really got to stop reading these short introductions to environmental politics. It's certainly one of the better ones, though I'm not sure it stands out in the way that other books of Wall's that I've read have done. All of a sudden, though, there's a sharp turn into some pretty heavy social movement theory, and the remainder of the book is much more compelling. Chapters on the methods of denial of the right, on the psychology of convincing others, of the failings of the state, and so much more round out the book. There's only really time to skate over these topics, as it's a pretty short book, but a good starter for deeper reading.
pdotb reviewed We're Not Broken by Eric Garcia
More for non-autists, but better than Silberman
4 stars
I've seen this book paired with "Unmasking Autism" which feels like a slightly odd choice. While that book felt like more of an actionable book, this feels more educational for people who don't know much about autism. I think it fills that role better than Silberman's book, which always seems to be held up as the 'first book you should read', partly because it's written 'from the inside', as it were, and partly because it doesn't suffer from that book's unfortunate perspective on Asperger. Still pretty useful, especially in its coverage of support needs and feeling comfortable requiring accommodations.













