Back
Judy Budnitz: If I told you once (1999, Picador USA) 4 stars

Review of 'If I told you once' on 'Goodreads'

4 stars

This was beautiful in places--I like the magical realism mixed with gritty and sometimes funny story that slowly reveals itself to be an immigrant tale. It was a bit unremittingly grim though. Didn't anyone ever have a happy marriage with surviving kids? Don't girls ever fail to get knocked up? Can't mothers and daughters ever communicate? Still, worth reading and Ilana, the matriarch, is a gripping, tough, magical character.