User Profile

pdotb Locked account

pdotb@wyrms.de

Joined 3 years, 7 months ago

Bookish version of pdotb@todon.eu

This link opens in a pop-up window

pdotb's books

To Read (View all 5)

Currently Reading

2024 Reading Goal

Success! pdotb has read 112 of 52 books.

Richard Seymour: Disaster Nationalism (Hardcover, 2024, Verso Books) 4 stars

The rise of the new far right has left the world grappling with a profound …

'the book is incredibly bleak'

4 stars

Funny coincidence: I finished the book last night, and then this morning was listening to Richard Seymour being interviewed on PTO, in which he described his own book as 'incredibly bleak'. While I think this characterization is true, I'm not sure it needed to be. The first couple of chapters are an interesting examination of the current political position, especially through the characters of Duterte, Modi, Bolsanaro, Orban, and, of course, Trump, while the last 'proper' chapter is a remarkably sober explanation of Israeli/Palestinian history and politics. In between, though, I felt like I was wading through a morass of incels, lone wolf shooters, and worse. Much, much worse. I'd definitely re-read the bracketing chapters for the analysis, but I'd skip the utter grimness in between :(

Katsi'tsakwas Ellen Gabriel: When the Pine Needles Fall (Paperback, 2024, Between the Lines) 5 stars

There have been many things written about Canada’s violent siege of Kanehsatà:ke and Kahnawà:ke in …

Eye-opening

5 stars

Just a stunning account of the so-called Oka Crisis of 1990, told in the form of a dialogue between a settler academic, Sean Carleton, and Katsi'tsakwas Ellen Gabriel, one of the chief spokespeople in the negotiations with the state, first with the SQ and then, ultimately, the Canadian army. The description of the standoff leads into a wider discussion including Gabriel's work with Quebec Native Women, and then more recent environmental actions such as that involving the Wet'suwet'en.

Katsi'tsakwas Ellen Gabriel: When the Pine Needles Fall (Paperback, 2024, Between the Lines) 5 stars

There have been many things written about Canada’s violent siege of Kanehsatà:ke and Kahnawà:ke in …

This stark process of taking land and of moving those on the land away is a hallmark of the United States and Canada, two nation-states where settlers stayed. The Kanehsatà:ke and Kahnawà:ke Siege of 1990, or the so-called Oka Crisis, the 78-day armed standoff between Mohawks and several forces of the state, remains one of the clearest manifestations of this process in North America to date. Mohawks were not only "in the way," the put themselves in the way of the extension of a nine-hole golf course that was to not only destroy sacred Pines for white leisure but was also to extend through a Mohawk burial ground.

When the Pine Needles Fall by  (Page 207)

Katsi'tsakwas Ellen Gabriel: When the Pine Needles Fall (Paperback, 2024, Between the Lines) 5 stars

There have been many things written about Canada’s violent siege of Kanehsatà:ke and Kahnawà:ke in …

But the use of force by policing authorities is a symptom of the problem. Police are doing the dirty work of corrupt politicians whose rhetoric upholds corporate greed, they're constantly repeating to themselves that they need to "balance" the so-called rights of all "stakeholders", which is just code for pandering to businesses and corporations while justifying the human rights violations of Indigenous Peoples. It should be understood that Indigenous rights are human rights, that we are more than just stakeholders, we are rights holders. I consider Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's words about reconciliation to be empty, meant to placate Indigenous people and the public. Trudeau says that no relationship is more important to him than Canada's relationship to Indigenous Peoples. But that's not what it feels like to me. His actions, or the lack of actions by his government, prove that little is changing in this country and that reconciliation is simply colonization repackaged.

When the Pine Needles Fall by  (Page 170 - 171)

Katsi'tsakwas Ellen Gabriel: When the Pine Needles Fall (Paperback, 2024, Between the Lines) 5 stars

There have been many things written about Canada’s violent siege of Kanehsatà:ke and Kahnawà:ke in …

Content warning violence

Katsi'tsakwas Ellen Gabriel: When the Pine Needles Fall (Paperback, 2024, Between the Lines) 5 stars

There have been many things written about Canada’s violent siege of Kanehsatà:ke and Kahnawà:ke in …

The Pines remain a very magical and spiritual part of the environment that I live in and grew up in. That connection to land is just something that you feel inside. And to know that it's being threatened because someone just wants to expand a golf course was frustrating-- that's what was proposed in the late 1980s and early 1990s, you know? What was even more insulting is that the developers were going to dig up our family members, our ancestors in our cemetery, to do it! That was just too much. It was an affront to us as Kanienʼkehá:ka. Our community of Kanehsatà:ke has been fighting these kinds of incursions on our lands for three hundred years now.

When the Pine Needles Fall by  (Page 9)

reviewed The Message by Ta-Nehisi Coates

Ta-Nehisi Coates: The Message (EBook, 2024, Random House Publishing Group) 4 stars

Good, but somehow not what I expected

4 stars

I came here off the back of that CBS interview, but was surprised to see how the book went. It's really three quite separate essays, held together by a common theme of the stories we tell ourselves, and how important writing and story telling are. The third essay has obviously attracted the most attention and, while it's definitely thought-provoking, I think it really suffers from being too short -- perhaps it should have been a book on its own? One of the principal points of the essay is that we really need more Palestinian voices in the media. The stories we're told matter as they construct our reality.