Reviews and Comments

pdotb Locked account

pdotb@wyrms.de

Joined 4 years, 7 months ago

Bookish version of pdotb@todon.eu

This link opens in a pop-up window

reviewed Late Victorian Gothic tales by Roger Luckhurst (Oxford world's classics)

Roger Luckhurst: Late Victorian Gothic tales (2005, Oxford University Press)

Somewhat mixed

This volume collects twelve Gothic tales, all from the 1890s, with an introduction by Roger Luckhurst. Oscar Wilde is, as expected, stunning, Henry James is also really rather good, and Arthur Machen creates a wonderful air of mystery and menace. Other stories were decidedly mediocre and I'd have happily not seen the ones by Kipling and Croker. Probably good as a survey of late nineteenth century Gothic, and I've at least found authors to pursue, but more mixed as an enjoyable read.

reviewed Dracula by Bram Stoker (Penguin Classics)

Bram Stoker: Dracula (Paperback, 2003, Penguin)

This diary style book by Bram Stoker continues to put fear into the hearts of …

Getting back in touch with my inner goth :)

I'd forgotten just how much fun Dracula is, and how wonderfully creepy it is in places, despite the rather forced epistolary style and the somewhat anti-climactic ending.

Hall, Stuart.: The hard road to renewal (1988, Verso)

Stuart Hall: needed now, more than ever

A perceptive analysis of the rise of Thatcherism, and the failure of the left to successfully combat it, this book reprints 19 essays that Hall wrote between 1978 and 1988. A couple of the essays around the middle of the book seemed a bit misplaced, including an analysis of the decline of liberalism around the turn of the 20th century, but so much of the rest of the book could, rather depressingly, have been written last week rather than 40 years ago. In particular, the emphasis on narratives and culture over policies, seems still hugely relevant. Also refers to his concept of "Authoritarian Populism" which, again, seems rather pertinent...

Phil Burton-Cartledge: Falling Down (2021, Verso)

More narrative than analysis

Apart from a brief survey of Fevre's distinction between 'sentimental' and 'cognitive' individualism, and the (short) concluding chapter, the book mostly consists of a narrative of the last forty years of UK politics, though through the lens of the Conservative party (i.e., there's no discussion of the internal struggles in the Labour party during the Thatcher/Major years, but there is coverage of the various Conservative leaders during the Blair/Brown years). Thus, it doesn't feel as if there's much/any room for discussion of the thesis that the party is in structural decline, though the narrative did serve to remind me just how incredibly awful they are.

Friederike Otto, Sarah Pybus: Angry Weather (2020, Greystone Books Ltd.)

Interesting, but not what I was hoping for

Maybe this is just my inner science nerd, but I was hoping for more of an explanation of how attribution science works. Instead, this is more the story of the creation of the World Weather Attribution project, and their ongoing work. Not a bad book, as such, but a bit unsatisfying.

Dara McAnulty: Diary of a Young Naturalist (2021, Milkweed Editions)

'This diary chronicles the turning of my world, from spring to winter, at home, in …

Excellent

Diary of a year in the life of a Northern Irish teenager, describing his (and his family's) close connection with the natural world, his keen observations, and their various expeditions, primarily in Fermanagh and County Down, interwoven with stories from Irish history and mythology. Also talks about his internal experience of autism in a remarkably evocative way. Highly recommended.

commented on Tintenherz by Cornelia Funke (Tinten-Geschichten (1))

Cornelia Funke: Tintenherz (Hardcover, German language, 2003, Dressler)

Wenn Bücher lebendig werden ... In einer stürmischen Nacht taucht ein unheimlicher Gast bei Meggie …

Given that it took me more than two months to read "Das kurze Leben der Sophie Scholl", this feels like it might be a bit ambitious, but: a) it (or, more accurately, "Inkheart") has a special place in my heart as the book that took my eldest from being able to read a couple of pages at a time to being able to read whole chapters at a time, and b) when I mentioned to them that I was thinking of reading it, but was daunted by the length, they said "go big or go home" which... I think was meant as encouragement ¯_(ツ)_/¯

Wood, James: How fiction works (Hardcover, 2008, Farrar, Straus and Giroux)

Provides a somewhat academic approach to a discussion of the main elements of fiction using …

Hard going

Admittedly I'm probably not part of the target audience for this book; it was recommended to me by someone with a BA in English Lit, though I never went past O-level, and that was quite some time ago. Still, this felt like hard work. There's a phrase in English something like "wears its learning lightly" and, to be frank, this book isn't it.

Kate Aronoff: Overheated (2021, PublicAffairs)

It has become impossible to deny that the planet is warming, and that governments must …

OK, but not great

This book has been quite hyped, and the reviewer quotes from the back cover certainly sing its praises, but I'm struggling to see how this sets itself apart from the other books that have come out more recently, inspired by the idea of a Green New Deal. If anything, the litany of tales of corruption and regulatory capture just felt rather disempowering, and the concluding chapter, which might have been a chance to pull it all together, just felt a bit all over the place.

Satish Kumar: Transformative Learning (2021, New Society)

A decidedly mixed experience

I started reading this as I thought Schumacher College sounded somewhat interesting (perhaps in part because I'd conflated it with CAT) and the book includes contributions from Ann Pettifor and Kate Raworth, among (many) others. As it's a celebration of 30 years of the college, though, practically every essay starts with a lengthy bit of praise for the college which, if I'm honest, starts to wear after a while. I have to confess to some misgivings about the content, too. While I can see the value in a more spiritual connection with the natural world, and can also see how that might be of value in forming/supporting an ecological outlook, the book felt far more apolitical than I really feel comfortable with. I can't quite put my finger on it, but it also felt dangerously much like it was heading into pseudoscience at some points (and, to be honest, I …

Chelsea Vowel: Indigenous Writes (Paperback, 2016, HighWater Press)

In Indigenous Writes, Chelsea Vowel, legal scholar, teacher, and intellectual, opens an important dialogue about …

Essential reading

Fantastic introduction to Indigenous issues in Canada, structured as 31 relatively self-contained essays, each of which has lots of endnotes/references for those who want to take it further. The author has lots more resources at apihtawikosisan.com

E.S. Yu: Human Enough (NineStar Press)

When Noah Lau joined the Vampire Hunters Association, seeking justice for his parents’ deaths, he …

Really sweet

Very good autistic representation and a sweet relationship between the two leads. Enjoyable read.

CW (from the publisher's website): Ableism, graphic violence, allusions to past emotional abuse, abduction, hate groups

Thomas Homer-Dixon: Commanding Hope (Alfred A. Knopf Canada)

Some good stuff, but ultimately unsatisfying

I'm afraid this seems to be a common theme in the books I'm reading on the topic of climate change. There's some good stuff earlier in the book, particularly on the importance of a more active form of hope, on critiquing techno-optimism, on different types of worldviews, and even on how to relate to people we don't agree with. Where it all starts to fall apart is towards the end where Homer-Dixon appears to be offering solutions. He critiques anti-capitalism approaches, though in a pretty strawman-like way (in particular by complaining about the former communist countries, without considering that the common factor is growth, and without engaging with the idea that capitalism requires growth in order to function), then goes on to advocate for a particular worldview (which he calls "Renew The Future" as opposed to "Mad Max") but then, unless I'm missing something, just leaps over the whole question …