I always thought "All Systems Red" was an absolute standout. Funny, and relatable, and thought-provoking in somewhat equal measure. The remaining three novellas felt somewhat flat after that, but this re-read has significantly changed my opinion. The first is still much funnier than the other three, but I now see their strength in developing the depths of Murderbot's character, becoming, if anything, even more relatable.
Reviews and Comments
Bookish version of pdotb@todon.eu
This link opens in a pop-up window
pdotb reviewed Exit Strategy by Martha Wells (The Murderbot Diaries, #4)
pdotb reviewed Britain in Fragments by Satnam Virdee
Quite excellent
5 stars
While the endpoint of the book is Brexit, it does such a good job of tracing the way the proletariat has been split, first through offering voting rights, but only to certain segments of the working class, and then during the twentieth century, by leaning on racism, xenophobia, and nationalism. Also good on the way Labour has generally acted as a diversion from anything more radical, and the way that the shift to the right under New Labour opened up space for nationalism. In Scotland this manifested as the SNP who occupied a position left of centre, but still to the right of Old Labour, but in England this led to the rise of first the BNP and then, when they imploded, UKIP.
pdotb reviewed The Memory Police by Yoko Ogawa
Melancholy dystopia
5 stars
Skillfully melds the fear of living in an oppressive dystopia with the melancholy of the loss of memories and, first, the objects they're tied to. Tends towards feeling pretty dark, leavened only by the obvious love between the main characters.
pdotb reviewed Convenience Store Woman by 村田沙耶香
Great except...
4 stars
Content warning spoilers
I felt like there was much joy in how Keiko had found her place in life, and fulfillment through doing a good job at the convenience store. Nicely critical of the way the people around her -- her so-called friends -- can't accept the choices she's made that make her happy and keep trying to push her into something else. The only sour note for me was Shiraha; I get why he's in the story, but every page with him on it was so unpleasant (perhaps I'd become weirdly protective of Keiko?) that I enjoyed the last third of the book much less than the preceding two-thirds.
Noir, but much more
4 stars
I haven't read a lot of noir, probably because it's always seemed just a bit too cynical. 'These Fragile Graces, This Fugitive Heart' translates noir into a dystopian near future with an anarchist commune and a trans MC, still feels like it has a lot of the key components of noir, but has so much more heart as it wrestles with what it is to be human, particularly a flawed one trying to find one's way in the world.
pdotb reviewed Toddler-Hunting and Other Stories by Taeko Kono
Weird but weirdly-compelling
4 stars
Collection of somewhat dark short stories (and I'm not sure 'Toddler-Hunting' is even the oddest), but when you get past the shock value there's lots to reflect on concerning topics such as marriage, childhood, illness, and death, but particularly through the lens of a woman in Japan in the sixties and the choices available, or not.
pdotb commented on I Want a Better Catastrophe by Andrew Boyd
pdotb reviewed McMindfulness by Ronald Purser
It's a bit ranty and repetitive, but I still appreciated it
4 stars
Purser appears to have multiple criticisms of the craze for secular mindfulness, among them that it's stripped of any ethical framework, that its claims of scientific backing seem pretty weak (TBH, I'm taking his word for that -- he does provide references, but I haven't followed them up yet), that it claims to be inspired by Buddhism when it's useful to do so, but then ditches it when it's useful to be purely secular and, perhaps most pointed, that it's ideally suited to corporate wellness programs as it mitigates the stress of the workplace without challenging anything about why work is the way it is. Can feel a bit overly ranty, and maybe too personally directed at Jon Kabat-Zinn in particular. Also leans towards being repetitive, though the latter part of the book does break this down quite well by having separate chapters about mindfulness in schools, for example, or …
Purser appears to have multiple criticisms of the craze for secular mindfulness, among them that it's stripped of any ethical framework, that its claims of scientific backing seem pretty weak (TBH, I'm taking his word for that -- he does provide references, but I haven't followed them up yet), that it claims to be inspired by Buddhism when it's useful to do so, but then ditches it when it's useful to be purely secular and, perhaps most pointed, that it's ideally suited to corporate wellness programs as it mitigates the stress of the workplace without challenging anything about why work is the way it is. Can feel a bit overly ranty, and maybe too personally directed at Jon Kabat-Zinn in particular. Also leans towards being repetitive, though the latter part of the book does break this down quite well by having separate chapters about mindfulness in schools, for example, or in the military. Purser does admit that Buddhism can also fail here, such as the support of the Zen establishment for Japanese militarism in the early twentieth century. He does appear to allow that it makes sense that individuals use mindfulness to ameliorate their own life conditions, and direct his anger at the corporate-friendly practitioners and teachers, but the book felt weakest in expounding alternatives.
pdotb commented on Blood Is Not Enough: Stories of Vampirism by Joe Haldeman
Content warning long, pretty negative
DNF'ing, which I should have done long before. The first few stories were at least an interesting take on vampirism, that's different from your usual blood-drinking count, though with the slight oddity that each story was followed by several paragraphs of the author explaining why they wrote it. In the ebook this wasn't even particularly set off from the story, which led to some confusion until I realized what was going on.
Things went downhill with Harlan Ellison's story, which was distinctly meh, and followed by pages of self-indulgent self-hagiography. I thought the name sounded familiar so I looked him up online and... yeah. It's not great when the 'Controversies' section of your Wikipedia page has ten sub-sections.
Not sure whether my lack of enthusiasm for the following stories is fair, or just tainted by Ellison's, but I'm done.
pdotb reviewed Empire of Normality by Robert Chapman
Good on history, somewhat weaker as a manifesto
4 stars
Interesting stuff on eugenics, the anti-psychiatry movement and particularly its links with libertarian thinking, the history of neurodiversity, and the way disability and capitalism interact. The concluding chapter or two felt like an attempt to sketch out a way forward, but seemed a little too tentative for me.
pdotb reviewed A Tale for the Time Being by Ruth Ozeki
Good until the deus ex machina
4 stars
Content warning spoilers, cw: suicide, bullying, sexual assault
I'm a bit torn as to how to review this. It was all going so well until the last fifty pages or so. Well, two of the main characters are suicidal for much of the book, and there's some pretty awful bullying going on, but it's still, somehow, enjoyable. All of a sudden things are neatly tied up by an intervention that comes out of nowhere, and then we're off into QM and Schrödinger's cat, and Everett's many-worlds interpretation, and I'm just wondering where the novel went to...
pdotb reviewed Fire Weather by John Vaillant
Three or four books welded together?
4 stars
Content warning climate crisis, wildfire
Felt like several rather disjoint narratives -- a pretty short history of the tar sands, a discussion of how wildfires are changing, a lengthy account of the Fort McMurray fire, followed by a lengthy history of climate change and the way fossil fuel companies have concealed the facts so they can keep making profits. The first and last are, unfortunately, nothing new. The discussion of how wildfires are changing was a real eye-opener (I've since looked up 'fire tornadoes' on YT and, yikes!) but the description of the fire in Alberta, while perhaps interesting as an illustration of how things are changing so fast that it's hard for people to comprehend, ultimately felt a bit like a thriller, but written about real peoples' lives. A bit mind-boggling, I will say, that Fort McMurray had a population of around 90,000!
pdotb commented on Empire of Normality by Robert Chapman
Forgot to mention that Robert Chapman is interviewed on the Pluto Books podcast: www.plutobooks.com/blog/podcast-empire-of-normality/
If you want to buy it, there's a discount code associated with the podcast.
I'm making my way through it pretty slowly, partly because I'm making so many notes and partly because I mismanaged my library ebook holds and far too many came in all at once! Really impressed so far, especially by the chapters on eugenics and anti-psychiatry.