Purser appears to have multiple criticisms of the craze for secular mindfulness, among them that it's stripped of any ethical framework, that its claims of scientific backing seem pretty weak (TBH, I'm taking his word for that -- he does provide references, but I haven't followed them up yet), that it claims to be inspired by Buddhism when it's useful to do so, but then ditches it when it's useful to be purely secular and, perhaps most pointed, that it's ideally suited to corporate wellness programs as it mitigates the stress of the workplace without challenging anything about why work is the way it is. Can feel a bit overly ranty, and maybe too personally directed at Jon Kabat-Zinn in particular. Also leans towards being repetitive, though the latter part of the book does break this down quite well by having separate chapters about mindfulness in schools, for example, or …
User Profile
Bookish version of pdotb@todon.eu
This link opens in a pop-up window
pdotb's books
2025 Reading Goal
15% complete! pdotb has read 8 of 52 books.
User Activity
RSS feed Back
pdotb started reading The Gothic Ideology by Diane Long Hoeveler
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8cc96/8cc96dc39592c2c5c797e152d8d390fc00c9f4f1" alt="Diane Long Hoeveler: The Gothic Ideology (EBook, 2014, University of Wales Press)"
The Gothic Ideology by Diane Long Hoeveler
Why have generations of readers been intrigued and entertained by tales of evil or persecuted nuns, lecherous monks, dank torture …
pdotb finished reading Loving-kindness in Plain English by Bhante H. Gunaratana
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fee0b/fee0b9b07512f704df99b89af5168559db0b19af" alt="Bhante H. Gunaratana: Loving-kindness in Plain English (Paperback, 2017, Wisdom Publications)"
Loving-kindness in Plain English by Bhante H. Gunaratana
The bestselling author of Mindfulness in Plain English invites us to explore the joyful benefits of living with loving-kindness. With …
pdotb started reading The Fascist Groove Thing by Hugh Hodges
pdotb started reading Loving-kindness in Plain English by Bhante H. Gunaratana
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fee0b/fee0b9b07512f704df99b89af5168559db0b19af" alt="Bhante H. Gunaratana: Loving-kindness in Plain English (Paperback, 2017, Wisdom Publications)"
Loving-kindness in Plain English by Bhante H. Gunaratana
The bestselling author of Mindfulness in Plain English invites us to explore the joyful benefits of living with loving-kindness. With …
pdotb finished reading McMindfulness by Ronald Purser
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2776f/2776f528bcac84702072eda84bd81f3a3f8c78fc" alt="Ronald Purser: McMindfulness (Paperback, 2019, Repeater)"
McMindfulness by Ronald Purser
Mindfulness is now all the rage.
From celebrity endorsements to monks, neuroscientists and meditation coaches rubbing shoulders with CEOs at …
pdotb reviewed McMindfulness by Ronald Purser
It's a bit ranty and repetitive, but I still appreciated it
4 stars
Purser appears to have multiple criticisms of the craze for secular mindfulness, among them that it's stripped of any ethical framework, that its claims of scientific backing seem pretty weak (TBH, I'm taking his word for that -- he does provide references, but I haven't followed them up yet), that it claims to be inspired by Buddhism when it's useful to do so, but then ditches it when it's useful to be purely secular and, perhaps most pointed, that it's ideally suited to corporate wellness programs as it mitigates the stress of the workplace without challenging anything about why work is the way it is. Can feel a bit overly ranty, and maybe too personally directed at Jon Kabat-Zinn in particular. Also leans towards being repetitive, though the latter part of the book does break this down quite well by having separate chapters about mindfulness in schools, for example, or in the military. Purser does admit that Buddhism can also fail here, such as the support of the Zen establishment for Japanese militarism in the early twentieth century. He does appear to allow that it makes sense that individuals use mindfulness to ameliorate their own life conditions, and direct his anger at the corporate-friendly practitioners and teachers, but the book felt weakest in expounding alternatives.
pdotb quoted McMindfulness by Ronald Purser
Kabat-Zinn likes to imagine that mindfulness will somehow undo this, making warriors kinder. "Even if mindfulness is used by the banker or the soldier to improve their professional skills," he once told Oprah Winfrey, "it will also nurture the innate compassion of their humanity." There is really no evidence for this fluffy idea.
— McMindfulness by Ronald Purser (64%)
pdotb stopped reading
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9c225/9c225f968def70db1b66d5e12a300d0181f212ee" alt="Joe Haldeman, Dan Simmons, Harlan Ellison, Gardner Dozois, Fritz Leiber, Tanith Lee, Edward Bryant, Pat Cadigan, Gahan Wilson, Garry Kilworth, Scott Baker, Leonid Andreyev, Harvey Jacobs, Sharon N. Farber, Susan Casper, Steve Rasnic Tem, Jack Dann, Chet Williamson: Blood Is Not Enough: Stories of Vampirism (2019, Open Road Media Sci-Fi & Fantasy)"
Blood Is Not Enough: Stories of Vampirism by Joe Haldeman, Dan Simmons, Harlan Ellison, and 15 others
pdotb commented on Blood Is Not Enough: Stories of Vampirism by Joe Haldeman
Content warning long, pretty negative
DNF'ing, which I should have done long before. The first few stories were at least an interesting take on vampirism, that's different from your usual blood-drinking count, though with the slight oddity that each story was followed by several paragraphs of the author explaining why they wrote it. In the ebook this wasn't even particularly set off from the story, which led to some confusion until I realized what was going on.
Things went downhill with Harlan Ellison's story, which was distinctly meh, and followed by pages of self-indulgent self-hagiography. I thought the name sounded familiar so I looked him up online and... yeah. It's not great when the 'Controversies' section of your Wikipedia page has ten sub-sections.
Not sure whether my lack of enthusiasm for the following stories is fair, or just tainted by Ellison's, but I'm done.
pdotb started reading Pachinko by Min Jin Lee
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0a469/0a46965f70dcf61f2728c1da9da03f045f7c98e1" alt="Min Jin Lee: Pachinko (2017)"
Pachinko by Min Jin Lee
In the early 1900s, teenaged Sunja, the adored daughter of a crippled fisherman, falls for a wealthy stranger at the …
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3fc4c/3fc4cd90a91e09644cf8ee13086f3bbc2e362de4" alt="avatar for pdotb"
slowly reading moss reviewed Unmasking Autism by Devon Price
A book I wish it would be translated into > 50 languages
5 stars
Radical and intriguing, this isn't the common book about Autism that you find in bookshelves, especially not written in languages other than English. This groundbreaking book, written by an Autistic and transgender author, is all about those hidden, 'masked' Autistics, especially from intersectionally marginalised populations, like Black, trans, women and other marginalised genders, and people with other disabilities on top.
Dr. Price takes a radical approach of harm reduction and social justice, identifying how much harm the ableist & capitalist society inflicts on Autistics (and on other neuro-divergent and disabled people, but really on everyone), forcing them into obscuring their disabilities, so that they can conform to 'normality' and function in an alienating, industrial society that punishes our quirks. The book helps neurodivergent people identifying their disability (seen from the social model of disability), and guides neuro-divergent people how they can actualise their own identity and identity their own values …
Radical and intriguing, this isn't the common book about Autism that you find in bookshelves, especially not written in languages other than English. This groundbreaking book, written by an Autistic and transgender author, is all about those hidden, 'masked' Autistics, especially from intersectionally marginalised populations, like Black, trans, women and other marginalised genders, and people with other disabilities on top.
Dr. Price takes a radical approach of harm reduction and social justice, identifying how much harm the ableist & capitalist society inflicts on Autistics (and on other neuro-divergent and disabled people, but really on everyone), forcing them into obscuring their disabilities, so that they can conform to 'normality' and function in an alienating, industrial society that punishes our quirks. The book helps neurodivergent people identifying their disability (seen from the social model of disability), and guides neuro-divergent people how they can actualise their own identity and identity their own values and worthiness. Because society often does not permit this, the book also aims to change society itself.
Throughout the book, we are guided through Heather R. Morgan's Values-Based Integration Process, which I still want to go through, especially as I am about to start a new chapter in my own life.
The only thing I really do not like about the book is that it is only available in English. There are huge knowledge gaps and language barriers when it comes to #ActuallyAustic, as lot of great resources on Autism written by Autistic authors are only available in English. As a consequence, a lot of stereotypes about (especially masked) autism still persist. I think translations of this and similar books could really counter them.
Books written from the perspective of intersectionally are very valuable. Personally, I really enjoyed that the author is transgender himself, and there are a lot of things I could personally identify with in his story and in the stories of the diverse set of interviewed Autistics.
pdotb started reading McMindfulness by Ronald Purser
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2776f/2776f528bcac84702072eda84bd81f3a3f8c78fc" alt="Ronald Purser: McMindfulness (Paperback, 2019, Repeater)"
McMindfulness by Ronald Purser
Mindfulness is now all the rage.
From celebrity endorsements to monks, neuroscientists and meditation coaches rubbing shoulders with CEOs at …
pdotb started reading Blood Is Not Enough: Stories of Vampirism by Joe Haldeman
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9c225/9c225f968def70db1b66d5e12a300d0181f212ee" alt="Joe Haldeman, Dan Simmons, Harlan Ellison, Gardner Dozois, Fritz Leiber, Tanith Lee, Edward Bryant, Pat Cadigan, Gahan Wilson, Garry Kilworth, Scott Baker, Leonid Andreyev, Harvey Jacobs, Sharon N. Farber, Susan Casper, Steve Rasnic Tem, Jack Dann, Chet Williamson: Blood Is Not Enough: Stories of Vampirism (2019, Open Road Media Sci-Fi & Fantasy)"