Back
Tim Jackson: Post Growth (Hardcover, 2021, Polity Press) 4 stars

"The relentless pursuit of more has delivered climate catastrophe, social inequality and financial instability – …

Beautiful, but...

4 stars

If I hadn't just read Jason Hickel's "Less is More", I'd have probably felt more enthusiastic about this book. It feels like they're covering fairly similar ground, but while Hickel's book is dense with ideas, Jackson's book contains some fantastic insights (a couple of which I quoted as I was reading the book), but adrift in a sea of biographical detail. Some of that is interesting (I didn't know anything about Robert F. Kennedy's economic programme, for example), but other parts felt pretty extraneous. Commentary on Lynn Margulis's marriage to Carl Sagan, for example, or Boltzmann's life story, including the sad circumstances of his death. There was also a long diversion on the stone bridge at Potter Heigham, Norfolk, which I think had a lesson in it, but I lost the point somewhere along the way. It's a more poetic book (quite literally, as the author is an Emily Dickinson fan) than Hickel's, and much heavier on human interest, but for someone looking for an introduction to degrowth I'd recommend "Less is More" over this, hands down.

@pdotb@wyrms.de I'm glad you left this review as I've read "Post Growth" but could only get through a small portion of "Less is More" before the library needed it back again. Your comment prompts me to get "Less is More" back again and finish it.

I loved "Post Growth" precisely for the extraneous parts you mention. It is poetic. And perhaps more approachable by the average person deterred by anything too heavy on the subject of economics. I do agree that his forays into other stories are not always clearly linked back to the central theme of the book but they do provide moments of humanity that are often lost in these sorts of educational books. I read "Post Growth" shortly after reading "Prosperity without Growth", which was far denser on the economic side, and found it refreshingly readable and approachable after the figures and numbers and thinking required for …

@shans@bookwyrm.social Thanks -- glad you liked it. "Less is More" is definitely worth a read; I'd say it was one of the best non-fiction books I read in 2021. Btw, Jason Hickel is on Mastodon too, though I don't think he posts very much.

Funny that you mention "Prosperity Without Growth". I have a vague recollection of starting to read it, but finding it too dense and dry to get very far with, and I gave up. I can well imagine "Post Growth" feeling like a refreshing change after that. :)