Reviews and Comments

Wild Woila

wildwoila@wyrms.de

Joined 3 years, 2 months ago

I have #mecfs so I have a lot of time for reading, mostly #fantasy and #SciFi but I'm happy to dip into nearly anything.

Ratings: 1 star: I didn't like it 2 stars: it was okay 3 stars: I liked it 4 stars: I really liked it 5 stars: it was brilliant

This link opens in a pop-up window

Eric A. Posner: Radical Markets (2018)

Many blame today’s economic inequality, stagnation, and political instability on the free market. The solution …

Proposes dramatic reforms to foundational institutions

Proposes a number of dramatic reforms to foundational institutions: including property, voting & migration. A perennial auction of property would result in shared public ownership funding a basic income and ensuring more efficient use of capital - this one challenged my deep set conception of ownership & control. Quadratic voting would enable citizens to give more democratic weight to issues of more concern to them - fantastic, we should do this! Would love to see these ideas get consideration and trial runs. We desperately need more creative thinking along these lines. No consideration given to environmental limits.

Becky Chambers: To Be Taught, If Fortunate (Paperback, 2020, Hodder Paperbacks)

At the turn of the twenty-second century, scientists make a breakthrough in human spaceflight. Through …

An ode to science, discovery and the inherent value of knowledge.

A small crew of scientists leave Earth, and their time period, forever to explore life on distant planets. But what will they do when Earth goes silent? An ode to science, discovery and the inherent worth of knowledge. The lack of interpersonal conflict under such trying conditions feels unrealistic.

reviewed A room of one's own by Virginia Woolf (Triad Panther book)

Virginia Woolf: A room of one's own (Paperback, 1982, Granada)

A Room of One's Own is an extended essay by Virginia Woolf, first published in …

Damn she can write

A classic that is actually good! An essay on women & fiction (thus, feminism) that rambles along in a relaxed fashion without losing any of its coherency or piercing insight. And damn she can write. Sadly still relevant, nearly 100 years on. (For reference her £500/yr is A$55k/yr today.)

Charlotte McConaghy: Once There Were Wolves (Hardcover, 2021, Flatiron Books)

Inti Flynn arrives in Scotland with her twin sister, Aggie, to lead a team of …

In wilderness we fear monsters, but perhaps the true monsters are within.

An attempt to reintroduce wolves to the Scottish Highlands faces strong pushback from the locals. In wilderness we fear monsters, but perhaps the true monsters are within. A thoroughly enjoyable thriller featuring the deep connection of twins, a remarkable form of empathy, the evil of domestic & ecological abuse and resultant trauma, and a little mystery. A strange lack of consequences.

Michael Mohammed Ahmad: The Lebs (2014, Hachette Australia)

Deeply uncomfortable

A deeply uncomfortable portrayal of Lebanese teenage boys in western Sydney as dumb, racist, misogynistic, sex-obsessed fundamentalists. The last third was more interesting, as the protagonist struggles with the foreignness & ugliness of the White world that he has always idolised.

Carlos Ruiz Zafón: The Shadow of the Wind (Paperback, 2005, Phoenix)

Hidden in the heart of the old city of Barcelona is the 'Cemetery of Forgotten …

Nearly great

A rare book sets a teenage boy on a path of mystery, love & revenge. This was nearly great, with an intriguing setup, smooth prose, vibrant characters and an evocative sense of time & place (mid-century Barcelona). But it ran out of steam with repetitive storytelling and too much exposition. And nearly all the men were incorrigible womanisers.

Toshikazu Kawaguchi: Before the Coffee Gets Cold (2021)

In a small back alley of Tokyo, there is a café that has been serving …

In an otherwise unremarkable cafe it is possible to travel through time

In a particular seat in an otherwise unremarkable cafe, it is possible to travel through time. Despite stringent limitations, the customers and workers nonetheless find solace from the travails of life. Its a pleasing enough community of everyday people, but nothing special.

Connie Willis: Blackout (Paperback, 2010, Spectra)

In her first novel since 2002, Nebula and Hugo award-winning author Connie Willis returns with …

Time travelling historians mired in the London Blitz

The Oxford time travellers are back, back to the London Blitz in WW2. But they are having trouble returning home, and getting caught up in all sorts of trouble in the meantime. Slow moving and overly detailed, but the near slapstick humour saves it. Only the first half of the story, so unfulfilling.

Gina Chick: We Are The Stars (Paperback, 2024, S&S/Summit Books)

Gina Chick, the inaugural winner of Alone Australia, tells the story of her extraordinary, indomitable …

Gina from Alone is awesome

That wild woman who captivated us on Alone Australia is the product of genes, a generous upbringing, and intense tempering in the crucible of life. A remarkable range of life experience, and an impressive capacity to learn & evolve from life's challenges. Heavy on nebulous metaphor, but fitting. I envy her capacity to inhabit her emotions & body so fully.

Carl Sagan: Contact (Paperback, 2022, Orbit)

We are not alone . . .

At first it seemed impossible – a …

Excruciating elite-level gaslighting

A message from outer space is detected, and humanity sets about decoding it, then attempts to make contact with the originators. Delves into the nexus of science & religion, the complexity of international collaboration, and the social upheaval of such a paradigm-shifting discovery. Some excruciating elite-level gaslighting. Surprising ending!

reviewed Wind and Truth by Brandon Sanderson (The Stormlight Archive, #5)

Brandon Sanderson: Wind and Truth (Paperback, 2024, Gollancz)

The long-awaited explosive climax to the first arc of the Number One New York Times …

Three weeks of amateur therapyis a bit much

An absolute brick of a book - possibly the longest I've ever read. Could certainly have been shorter (successful authors get way too much latitude), with too frequent changes in PoV, and while I appreciate his use of mental health to disrupt tired fantasy tropes, after three weeks of amateur therapy I was a bit over it. But he does pull together sprawling plot lines to a satisfying climax, with an appealing set up for a fresh take on the second half of the series.

Paul Lynch: Prophet Song (Hardcover, 2023, Oneworld Publications)

On a dark, wet evening in Dublin, scientist and mother-of-four Eilish Stack answers her front …

Encroaching terror is disturbingly relatable

A horrifying realistic account of an everyday Western country being gradually consumed by an authoritarian regime. Every moment of encroaching terror is disturbingly relatable. Writing style felt like a monotone ramble, which masked its poignancy.

reviewed The World We Make by N. K. Jemisin (The Great Cities, #2)

N. K. Jemisin: The World We Make (Hardcover, 2022, Orbit)

All is not well in the city that never sleeps. Even though the avatars of …

A role for Mamdani?

New York finishes the job against the Multiverse, despite the reticence of the Old Cities. Clunkier and without the freshness of the original. But fun to see more city avatars. I think Mamdani could easily be a character in these books.

China Miéville: The Scar (Paperback, 2004, Del Rey)

A mythmaker of the highest order, China Mieville has emblazoned the fantasy novel with fresh …

An exuberant steampunk world

An exuberant, barely believeable steampunk world with cactus & mosquito people, underwater & floating cities, and mysterious powers. Very very long, and rather too serious.